CadillacSee TIFF on JAM!


December 21, 2007
Jam
Music
Movies
      Actors A-Z
      Movie Reviews
      US Box Office
      Movie Listings
      Watch Classic Films
      Oscars
      TIFF 2011

Television
Video
Theatre
Books
Country




ENT Blog
RSS Feed

MACCA



'Charlie Wilson's War' loses its nerve
By -- Sun Media




Watch the trailer!
Behind the scenes of 'War'

For a satire to bite, someone has to draw blood.

Cue Philip Seymour Hoffman -- in his third dynamite performance of 2007, following Before The Devil Knows You're Dead and The Savages -- as CIA agent Gust Avrakotos, the one coarse, blunt-edged weapon in director Mike Nichols' otherwise dulled arsenal. He's not the only reason to see Charlie Wilson's War, a sophisticated, snappy account of how you can fund a military operation without telling the public, but he's by far the most persuasive. Can someone please give this man an Oscar? What's that -- they already have? Well, give him another one. Or four.

Tom Hanks, also a producer, stars as Wilson, a boozing, womanizing, Democratic congressman from Texas -- hounded by conservatives for his personal indiscretions -- who emerged the principal, and unprincipled, force behind the expulsion of the Soviets from 1980s Afghanistan.

Adapted by West Wing creator Aaron Sorkin, the script follows Wilson for a decade as he cons, cajoles and manoeuvres power players in Washington, Egypt, Israel and Pakistan to orchestrate the downfall of the Soviet Union's Afghan occupation. In doing so, he finds two well-positioned allies -- his sometimes-lover Joanne Herring (Julia Roberts), a right-wing Texas socialite and millionaire, and Avrakotos, a gruff, mustachioed black-ops rogue whose only career ambition is to "kill some Russians."

Together, they supplied arms to the Afghan mujahideen without ever implicating -- or consulting -- the U.S. If that sounds like a big chunk of history to cover in a scant 97 minutes, it is -- and sometimes the breakneck pace comes at the expense of the storytelling.

For his part, Hanks plays Wilson as more a likeable scoundrel than a corrupt politico -- even if you're not sure if you should be rooting for someone so skilful at manipulating the system -- and the chemistry he shares with Hoffman is one of the film's great pleasures. Less impressive? Roberts -- brittle and unconvincing, in and out of the bedroom -- and the movie's final, too-timid third act. Timid because, with the exception of an end-credit quote, Nichols skirts around the obvious: That by driving out the Soviets and then not following through with substantive social aid, the U.S. created an arena for Islamic extremists, the Taliban and al-Qaida.

Why the cold filmmaking feet? It's been reported the real-life Herring was responsible, going so far as to apply legal pressure to muzzle Sorkin's original, more pointed script.

Whatever the reason, the results are significant: Curtailing a war just as it looks won, and leaving audiences with the impression of a well-oiled skirmish.

(This film is rated 14A)
More Movie Reviews


HOT MUSIC HEADLINES
Brand suffers migraine attack onstage
Berry kid to be 'American only'?
Robin Wright dating co-star?
Culkin in 'perfectly good health': Rep
Kodak Theatre name in question
Breaking the myths of Disney
Farrelly brother's son, 20, dies
Best bets for Oscar glory in 2012
Cyrus not college bound
'The Vow' a V-Day gift for her
More Headlines
'Journey 2' just plain silly
'Safe House' a safe bet for action
Wilson, Vaughn reunite for comedy
Swinton 'Kevin' role Oscar-worthy
Berry fearing escaped patient?
Watts cast as Princess Diana
'Paradise Lost' film shut down
Berry seeks move out of U.S.
Bullock laughs at dating rumours
Ramsay on her 'domestic thriller'


Who's coming and when
Want to know when your favourite band is coming to town? Check out Clive, JAM Music's extensive Canadian concert listings.

TV Listings
Wondering what's on tonight? Check out our TV listings for the complete schedule in your area.
Movie Listings
Find out what's playing at a theatre near you.






What did you think of Madonna’s halftime show?
She’s still got it
I wasn’t impressed


Results