CadillacSee TIFF on JAM!


July 22, 2005
Jam
Music
Movies
      Actors A-Z
      Movie Reviews
      US Box Office
      Movie Listings
      Watch Classic Films
      Oscars
      TIFF 2011

Television
Video
Theatre
Books
Country




ENT Blog
RSS Feed

MACCA


Movie Review: The Island

'The Island' is a fun but silly escape
Like a fun Kubrick flick 'without a brain'
By BRUCE KIRKLAND - Toronto Sun


PLOT: In the year 2019, a restless and inquisitive resident of a post-apocalyptic city begins to discover that all is not as it seems -- and his life may be in serious danger.

Big, dumb, stupid fun. That's life on The Island.

No doubt, Michael Bay's summer popcorn flick will be thrashed and trashed by most critics as empty of meaning, ludicrous in plotting and ridiculous in its hokey, quasi-religious ending.

All that is absolutely true.

Yet there is something compelling about watching it. This movie is so bad it's good, especially because Ewan McGregor helps sell the silliness with a strong performance that would have worked in a much more serious film.

Meanwhile, pouty Scarlett Johansson, while wasted for the most part as a sidekick character, looks good doing it.

In the end, The Island feels as if master Stanley Kubrick were reborn without a brain, given a bigger budget and asked to remake Escape From Alcatraz -- or Bay's own hit movie The Rock -- as a futuristic sci-fi thriller.

Just don't go expecting anything as sophisticated as 2001: A Space Odyssey. Keep your eyes wide, your brain shut.

As Island opens, the year is 2019. We are deep inside a post-apocalyptic, hi-tech facility where streaming columns of white-clad worker bees go about their business, dreaming of winning a lottery. Those winning individuals are promised a wondrous dream: Escape to a contamination-free zone on an island paradise. Hence, the title.

Inside the facility, however, the people -- such as the ones played by McGregor and Johansson -- are treated as drones who attend to their mindless tasks while being monitored for even minute variations in their metabolism and health.

Under the control of the friendly villain (Sean Bean), this is a sexless world, too, so the routine is boring. Interaction longer than seconds between men and women is strictly forbidden. Virginal McGregor is left to pine vaguely for more intense contact with the similarly naive Johansson.

But our hero is just not staying with the program. His mind is wandering. Things just don't feel right, especially in his interactions with a slovenly computer whiz (Steve Buscemi, who gets the movie's only snappy lines of dialogue).

McGregor becomes curious about what is behind the facade. Curiosity killed the cat, but don't forget the kicker -- satisfaction brought him back. Whether McGregor ever gets his satisfaction is at the heart of the story, such as it is.

But, really, this being a Michael Bay movie with even more crash-and-burn special effects scenes than in Armageddon, any human concerns are secondary. The plot is just an excuse to get to the elaborate chase sequences involving a vigilante warrior dude (Djimon Housou).

These sequences are all spectacular, of course. That's where the budget went, into digital effects. Bay & Co. certainly did not spend much time and money filling in the holes in the plot, nor trying to make sense of anything as McGregor and Johansson insult logic in their death-defying stunts.

Just as he did in The Rock, however, Bay makes it fun. As long as you don't listen to your inner voice saying: "Empty, ludicrous, ridiculous!"

(This film is rated PG)
More Movie Reviews


HOT MUSIC HEADLINES
Farrelly brother's son, 20, dies
Best bets for Oscar glory in 2012
Cyrus not college bound
'The Vow' a V-Day gift for her
'Journey 2' just plain silly
'Safe House' a safe bet for action
Wilson, Vaughn reunite for comedy
Swinton 'Kevin' role Oscar-worthy
Berry fearing escaped patient?
Watts cast as Princess Diana
More Headlines
'Paradise Lost' film shut down
Berry seeks move out of U.S.
Bullock laughs at dating rumours
Ramsay on her 'domestic thriller'
Speedman a big fan of McAdams
Banderas 'hated' Hayek during tour
'Karate Kid' to fight again
Aniston: Pitt-Jolie 'feud' made up
Radcliffe miffed at Oscar snub
Downey, Jr., wife welcome son


Who's coming and when
Want to know when your favourite band is coming to town? Check out Clive, JAM Music's extensive Canadian concert listings.

TV Listings
Wondering what's on tonight? Check out our TV listings for the complete schedule in your area.
Movie Listings
Find out what's playing at a theatre near you.






What did you think of Madonna’s halftime show?
She’s still got it
I wasn’t impressed


Results